Profiles

It’s hard to imagine an Internet in which The Onion doesn’t exist. As far as satirical news is concerned, no one does it better. In a post from spring, The Onion took on online dating and…well…the results are exactly as hilarious as you'd expect them to be.

The Onion’s top tips for finding love online include:

• It’s important to choose an interesting profile picture that reflects the “real you” persona that you’ve cooked up, like a photo of you hiking or at a volunteer event.
• To stand out in a sea of suitors, include something in your profile completely unique to you, like your social security number and checking account information.
• Be willing to open yourself up to new experiences, like going on a series of terrible dates with men you despise.
• Personal details give potential dates a more accurate picture of who you are. Be specific in your profile by mentioning the exact episode and scene that made you give up on Lost.
• Humor is a huge asset in any dating profile. Be charmingly self-deprecating with lines like “I have a soft spot for reality television” and “I’m a bad listener because I’m wrapped up in my own childish self-obsession and do nothing to improve myself.”
• Remember to relax and have fun! Sometimes, the moment you stop worrying about finding that perfect match is the moment you’ll open your email and find an absolutely vulgar and disgusting email from a complete stranger.

So yes, they’re funny…but The Onion’s tips aren’t quite as useless as you think, as long as you’re willing to read between the lines. Look at it this way:

• Photos are a great way to show your personality without have to write about it, which can be tedious to do and boring to read. Choose photos that show you doing what you love, like playing an instrument, traveling the world, or attending a NASCAR race.
• Safety should be taken seriously. Don’t put any identifying information on profile. That includes everything from your phone number to your work address to, yes, your SSN and checking account info.
• Online dating doesn’t work unless you come to it with an open mind. Take a chance on someone who doesn’t immediately tick off every one of your boxes. You might be surprised.
• Including unique personal details is a great way to attract the attention of likeminded suitors. Not everyone will understand your Doctor Who reference if you’re a sci-fi fan, but the ones who do might be better matches for you.
• Humor is a huge asset in a dating profile…just make sure it’s actually funny.
• Remember to relax and have fun! Sometimes, the moment you stop worrying about finding that perfect match is the moment you’ll open your email…and actually find that perfect match.

See? The Onion’s dating advice isn’t nearly as useless as it should be.

After years of off-again, on-again relationship, dates that didn’t go anywhere, and, yes, online dating, one of my best friends finally seems to be in a great relationship. They’re approaching a year together, with no end in sight.

They happened to meet at a series of company events, but they both have online dating profiles on the same sites. Naturally, one might wonder: why didn’t they meet sooner?

The answer is that they filtered one another out. For one thing, the guy - Steve - is a good twenty years older than his girlfriend, Lisa. Though Lisa was open to dating older men, twenty years was a bit out of her comfort zone. For another, Steve has children. Lisa wasn’t interested in having kids. However, dating an older man means that the children are grown and out of the house, and for Lisa, that’s a horse of a different color.

On Steve’s part, he too had filtered Lisa out due to her age, assuming he wouldn’t have anything in common with someone that much younger. He had also filtered out anyone with cats, as he’s allergic. In an odd twist of fate, Lisa’s pet cat had passed on earlier, and she had no plans to get another, but she hadn’t thought to update her profile.

Despite their “differences,” a quick perusal of their profiles would have revealed that they still had much in common - everything from their tastes in pop culture to their political opinions. And while there are differences, they aren’t on the opposite ends of the spectrum. If they’d seen one another’s profiles, they might well have messaged each other.

But they didn’t. They’d each filtered the other out, and met solely on chance.

There’s nothing wrong with using the filter tools of an online dating site; they can help cut through the white noise and help you make sense of the sheer number of options. But if you’ve become familiar with your site, and you feel like you’ve perused all your current options, it might be worth experimenting with peeling back your filters, one at a time. What if you didn’t place a restriction on body type? What if you didn’t worry about a height difference?

There are exceptions to every rule - but identifying those exceptions is still a task left up to the human heart, not an algorithm. Severe search options clean up your list of options, but occasionally it doesn’t hurt to allow a little mess.

Related Article: Stories in Success, Part II

I often hear complaints from both sexes about online dating. Guys think that they have the harder time, because they have to pursue. A lot. Most of them assume women get too many emails and therefore never respond.

Women on the other hand, feel that they have it tougher. They think the guys send sexually aggressive emails, hoping to just see who’s down to hook up rather than go on an actual date. Most of the other guys are either mass-emailing women, or they just don’t know what to talk about and don’t even bother to engage with women outside of the standard phrase: “how was your day?”

Together, it makes online dating tough for both sexes.

I don’t think it’s a competition for who has it worst. I think that there is a lot of room for improvement on both sides. Instead of spending more time complaining about the opposite sex and their online dating strategies, try thinking about what you do personally – what do you say in your profile? What is it that you are actually looking for? How are you coming across to strangers?

When you focus on what you can control in online dating – you and your profile – then you can begin to make some changes and see what works and what doesn’t instead of just complaining. Here are some suggestions if you’re having trouble thinking of what to say in a first email, or if you’re not having much luck:

Guys:

Read her profile. Chances are, if she’s online dating she’s left you a lot of valuable information about what she likes in her profile. Start from there – send an email specifically about something in her profile so she sees that you read it, that your email is a bit more personal. It makes a good impression.

Put some time into it. Don’t just mass-email 100 women because you think only 5% will respond. That’s because they know you’ve just sent a mass email! Instead, pick the women you find most attractive and send them a personal message. It’s not about writing a novel, it’s about being less generic in your approach.

Ladies:

Answer more emails. Instead of just writing guys off (unless they are being inappropriate), try responding to more emails. Agree to meet more guys for coffee. There’s nothing wrong with deciding later whether you want to pursue him or not. Don’t discount him until you get to know him.

Be polite. There’s no need to write a nasty response or let your emails go unanswered if you feel he’s not exactly right. It’s very easy to say a quick “thanks, but no thanks.” After all, he took the time to write. So if he’s polite, he deserves a little respect in return.

Dating is full of clichés, and online dating is even worse. If I see one more person who describes themselves as “fun” or says they like “hanging out with friends” (or, God forbid, that they like “candlelit dinners and long walks on the beach”) I am going to throw my laptop out the window in a fit of rage. Could you possibly be any more boring?

Most online clichés should be ignored, but there’s one overused online dating phrase that’s worth paying attention to: “no drama.”

Yes, it sounds incredibly annoying and to be honest I would probably never date someone who used it. That being said, I do think it has value. We all like to complain about the drama others bring into our lives, but when was the last time you stopped to ask yourself if you’re the reason there's drama in your relationships? If you find yourself in bad relationship after bad relationship, it's time to face the music: the common denominator is you.

Next time you see an online dating profile that says drama queens need not apply, ask yourself a few questions:

• Are you ready to have fun? If a new relationship is coming directly on the heels of the previous one, you may not have given your self sufficient time to heal. On the other hand, if it's been forever since you last dipped your toes in the dating pool, you might be feeling totally lost. Getting back into the swing of things means being comfortable with being uncomfortable. Sometimes you’ll be rejected. Sometimes someone you're interested in will simply disappear. Sometimes a date will go totally haywire. If you're not ready to face every eventuality – and have fun while doing it - there's a good chance drama will follow.
• How confident are you? Dating isn't always easy. In fact, it can be downright brutal. Things will happen that will make you forget how totally awesome you are. The minute your confidence takes a hit, you start behaving in ways that sink it even further. Low self-esteem leads to neediness, to dependency, and to attention-seeking behavior. When you don't feel good about yourself internally, you'll find yourself desperately seeking external validation. None of this is healthy. None of this is attractive. And all of it = drama.
• Have you fully moved on from your last relationship? Hello, drama central! One of the easiest ways to doom a relationship is to enter it before you're ready. It’s never smart to start dating right away after the end of a relationship. It might feel like a fix, but that fix is only temporary. You’ll end up dragging the baggage from the previous relationship over to the new one, dooming things with your new date from the very beginning. When a relationship ends, stay single until you're ready to date again with confidence, happiness, an open heart, and absolutely zero ex drama.

When you’re online dating, it’s important to be realistic about who you are and what you want. It’s also important to know when you’re carrying baggage along from past dates or relationships.

But let’s face it - it’s hard to be objective about our love lives. After all, our experiences shape our world. If we encounter people who don’t treat us well, or who take advantage or betray us, or otherwise disappoint, we start to look for evidence in each new person of how they might let us down, too.

This kind of emotional baggage is something all of us have. Whether it stems from the break-up of a long-term relationship or a series of potential partners letting us down, we can carry those hurts along with us. We make them part of our story. And we do our best to avoid engaging with these types of people again. Or at least, we try.

There’s an art to attracting a woman’s attention – especially when it’s through your online dating profile. The biggest mistake I see guys make is assuming that women will automatically respond to their emails or overtures – when the truth is, most women are bombarded with messages.

You have to cut through the clutter to make a good impression. It’s up to you to make your profile stand out so that she will want to respond. Maybe it doesn’t seem fair that guys have to work a bit harder in that respect, but that’s the reality. And isn’t it worth it to meet a great woman?

Following are some tips to give your profile a competitive edge:

Be yourself – not your resume. As cliché as this sounds, there really is meaning behind it. No woman wants to hear all of your work accomplishments or accolades, she wants to know if she can connect with you. Instead of crafting a resume, try expressing what you’re passionate about, what you want to learn, or your sense of humor.

Watch the grammar! Proofing is the most important thing you can do for your profile, at least according to the latest Match.com study. The vast majority of women want to know that you can put a sentence together (not text-speak). Considering how many people leave incomplete profiles with poor grammar, this will give you an advantage.

Stay away from selfies. Have you been working out? Do you want to show off your six-pack? Please don’t. Even if you look great, your matches will be turned off because you’re showing yourself to every single woman on the site. Instead of taking that shirtless selfie, try taking a picture playing a guitar instead. Studies have shown that if you include shots of yourself doing something active – especially playing a guitar or musical instrument – you’ll get more responses.

Be sincere, not generic. It might seem easier to write things you think women will want to hear, but it will work against you. “I like long walks on the beach” will cause her to scroll right past you. Instead of going for cliché try injecting your personality into the mix. What do you really like? Where would you take her on your ideal date? What’s your favorite memory from childhood? These details into who you are will capture her attention.

Complete the profile. So many men leave profiles blank or hide photos, which will cause a woman to think you’re hiding something (maybe a girlfriend). Don’t write an essay or refuse to post photos, but DO use complete sentences and try not to leave anything blank. If it looks like you spent about five minutes filling out your profile, she’ll notice. A little more effort goes a long way.