Are Background Checks An Effective Way To Avoid Online Dating Criminals?
- Thursday, February 10 2011 @ 09:02 am
- Contributed by: ElyseRomano
- Views: 2,037
You know your date is attractive, well-educated, and into electronic music. But do you know if your date has a criminal record?
For a small fee, a group of companies like the ones we discussed in this article will run a background check on all potential partners found on dating sites like Match.com and eHarmony. As the online dating industry explodes, it becomes increasingly important to protect yourself from the sexual predators and convicted felons that find their victims online. Now that 20 million Americans are registered on dating sites, more than double the number of dating site members 5 years ago, two states, New York and New Jersey, have started regulating online dating sites, and "legal experts say they believe changes to the liability laws that protect such sites are on the horizon."
"No one [like the Department of Justice's Bureau of Justice Statistics or the National Center for Victims of Crime] has put a number on how much violence stems from dating sites," reports New York Times writer Stephanie Rosenbloom in a recent article called "New Online-Date Detectives Can Unmask Mr. or Ms. Wrong," but it seems many modern tragic stories, like the case of serial rapist Jeffrey Marsalis, begin with the perpetrator searching for victims on online dating sites. State officials, public safety advocates, and entrepreneurs are leading the charge for further safeguards, but in an environment in which it's common to lie about simple things like age and weight, will it be possible to effectively screen out criminals?
Robert Buchholz and Andrew J. Scott, a retired New York State Police captain and former police chief in Boca Raton, Fl., respectively, believe there's hope. Together, Buchholz and Scott founded a site called MyMatchChecker.com, which will perform a basic background check on potential mates for $9.95. Mobile phone apps that allow dating site users to research potential mates before meeting up, like "Date Check" from Intelius and the "Instant National Criminal Search" app created by ValiMate, are becoming popular as well.
Some state officials also believe that it's possible to make online dating safer. A law recently passed in New York, the Internet Dating Safety Act, requires dating sites to post common-sense safety tips, like "always meet in a public setting," for their members to read. A similar law passed in New Jersey in 2008, requiring "dating sites with a membership fee to inform users whether they do criminal background checks (most do not)," while other states have rejected comparable legislation.
Mandy Ginsberg, general manager and executive vice president of Match.com, remains skeptical: "If I really knew that there was a great ability for us to not let anyone on the site that shouldn't be on the site, I would do it," she says, but she fears that background checks will lead online daters to assume that everyone they encounter on a dating site is safe, when in reality it's impossible to guarantee. Other critics point out that most background checks could easily be thwarted, some have mishandled information, and others could put personal information in the hands of people who will abuse it.
But all hope is not lost. Braden Cox, a policy counsel for a group called NetChoice that advocates for Internet companies, firmly believes that "Most people, thankfully, are good people on these Web sites," and Parry Aftab, a lawyer and safety expert, offers the most useful advice of all: "Don't give up your heart so fast."
