I tried an experiment on Plenty of Fish with my photo for my profile this week. Before, I always put up a photo of me smiling. Well in the past month I haven't had much luck so I changed the photo to one where I am not and in which I have an arrogant look.
To my surprise I got many more views and about twice the messages. The photos are pretty similar other than my facial expression. I actually took the photo the same night as the other one but rejected it since I thought it wasn't one that would get responses.
Why is this? Do women like men who are more serious?