I've utilized Match since my divorce three years ago, and it is decidedly not a scam. It has been my primary method of meeting women, although it's a bit of an art that needs to learned. It's a conversational approach, so some opposite sex social skills need to be developed, you will make plenty of mistakes. Key, chalk it up to a learning experience and don't dwell on it. Obviously women need to feel safe to meet you, so would recommend plain daylight in public and rather nice places. There are women on Match who have a hard time getting off the dime, and with them would recommend moving on, and avoiding endless e mailing, or phone chats. I just ask plain and simple, would you like to meet at such and such a place?
I typically meet new women on Saturday or Sunday afternoons (rarely evenings), right in my own neighborhood. I will even joke to them, because often the same waitress takes the order, so they know I'm a fixture, and am not going to be able to get away with anything of ill intent, too much evidence.
The quality of Match women has generally been pretty high too. You probably won't meet glamour models, but the people are by and large mainstream, and plenty of attractive, and at least acceptable gals. There's some deception (smokers who say not smokers, ten year old photos)at times, but it's not epidemic, if you are smart and alert. It can be work, but most experiences are enjoyable even if they end with a handshake. I had several fine girl friends of the six month variety. I've had some short flings that haven't worked out, and yes there's wild one night stands to found as well, if that's what you want. No set pattern, pretty much runs the gamut of men and women out there in the real world. If one is inclined and has attractive qualities, think one can stay pretty active socially there.