I posted earlier about by observations about what's going on with AM. Here's some more info and advice for you. This comes from my own research and from meeting over a dozen real women on AM (online and in person) and asking about their experiences. Any women readers who read this are invited to comment.
I've been lucky enough to chat and meet many women through AM (though none have been what I'm really looking for). The women are there, though in far fewer numbers than you'd believe based on the AM hype (and your own fantasies).
Most of the women I met are very nice, each with an interesting story about why they're there. Ironically, many are there because their boyfriends/husbands cheated on them earlier. Some are there because they are missing passion and intimacy, so not looking for multiple partners, more looking for a "special someone" (their own fantasy).
To get women to talk to you you need three things right off the top:
1. You should send a short but interesting personal message (forget winks, they ignore them). Say something positive on their profile or have a witty thing to say.
2. You should think hard and make a damn good profile. DO NOT list what you want and don't want in a woman, instead describe yourself in the bet possible way. Women read those profiles!
3. Get a couple of DECENT photos of yourself that show you as a quality, charming, handsome man. Smile! And my god, DO NOT show your anatomy!! Every woman I talked to says this is a turnoff, or at best, something to laugh about. If you're getting a woman who asks for photos of your private parts, you can bet it's some teenagers having a big laugh at your expense.
Those are the only three impressions you have to get them to contact you, so make them count. Remember that you are competing against many, many men. By my estimate the ratio is something like 10 or 20 men to 1 real woman. And many of the women are "just curious" and will not really follow up, so the real ratio for available women is probably lower. The game is stacked in the women's favor, so it is easy for them to overlook you. Too bad really, because the women may miss out on some quality people (sometimes it takes time to find a real Prince Charming). But that's how it is, unfortunately.
As soon as possible, get them to use regular email to continue the conversation so they don't have to log on to AM. First, many women can't use the AM website all the time for fear of getting discovered. Second, this way they are more likely to see your future emails, instead of it being buried among 100's of others on the AM site. Third, you don't want them seeing other guy's messages while they're looking at yours. You're in competition with many other men (including me), so get them off AM as fast as possible!
Keep in mind that (for the most part) we are talking about regular people here, not women from porn fantasies. Remember, unless she's looking for a sugar daddy or money, she's taking a huge risk by being on this site. So she needs to feel safe and comfortable with you. These are not party sex girls, most are ordinary women who have ventured our beyond the norm. Also remember that they have their own fantasy at it probably revolves around meeting a "Mr. Right" on the side who makes them feel wonderful. Will they actually take this all the way? Hard to say, fantasy is one thing, but fulfilling it is another. We are talking about real people, not porn fantasies.
Now there are a few outliers and interesting phenomena that you should be aware of. First, there are (very few) women who are indeed looking for multiple partners without expecting money. However, they are very strange people, so be warned! (One that I met truly scared me!) The second observation is this very interesting phenomenon: Because these women are bombarded by men seeking their attention, many start to adopt a "princess" mentality and begin to value themselves much higher than they normally would. They end up using superficial criteria to filter men out. I have met women that I would normally not spend effort trying to make time with, describe to me their silly criteria they used to reject guys. It's a shame because they could very easily be filtering out very good men. But when you've got 10 more lined up ready to meet you, this is what happens. Also, they become desensitized to the rejection process. So consequently, many can seem like "bitches" and what is supposed tone a fun meet up can seem like a job interview. Fortunately, I have not had any major negative experiences (your own frame of mind can help a lot here), but when they tell me about their other meet ups and how they turned away other guys (and how badly guys react, ranging from getting angry to begging for another chance), I can only shake my head.
Bottom line is this. Perhaps you can find someone to enjoy for some time on AM--there are real women there. But there are very few real women, and a LOT of noise. Make your best impression online and keep in mind who's really there (real ordinary women from real marriages). Love them for who they are, not for your sex fantasy. Do not take anything personally. Many women are passing up real gems (possibly you) because they have to deal with volume and they don't know how to handle that kind of attention. And many are fooling themselves, playing within their own fantasy (like shopping for clothes). Consider your money spent on AM as an adventure. A good night at the bar with my friends is going to cost me $80. If you can't afford $50 for a month of activity, how are you gong to afford an affair?
Good luck guys!